Comment: Unresol­ved compa­ny succes­si­ons endan­ger our prosperity

Two topics have been on my mind these days. These were a family-inter­nal compa­ny succes­si­on in Espel­kamp and a study by the Regens­burg Chamber of Indus­try and Commer­ce on unresol­ved genera­tio­nal changes in family businesses. Unresol­ved compa­ny succes­si­ons in parti­cu­lar could endan­ger our prospe­ri­ty in the future.

But let’s start with the compa­ny succes­si­on in Espel­kamp. Paul Gausel­mann, owner of the public limit­ed compa­ny of the same name and Germany’s slot machi­ne king, spoke to the Neue Osnabrü­cker Zeitung (NOZ) about the genera­ti­on change in the compa­ny he founded in 1964, among other things.

The 82-year-old Gausel­mann revea­led to the NOZ that he is not yet thinking of quitting. Although: In the meanti­me, he would like to pass the baton to his 62-year-old son. But that topic has been settled. 20 years ago he would have wanted to,” Gausel­mann told the NOZ, “but I wasn’t ready then. The promi­nent compa­ny succes­si­on in Espel­kamp has nevert­hel­ess been solved: with the trans­fer of Gausel­mann AG to a family founda­ti­on, the compa­ny will be kept in the family for the long term.

Founda­ti­ons to solve family-inter­nal compa­ny successions

A Founda­ti­on soluti­on can be a very good instru­ment for succes­si­on, but is only likely to be used in a minori­ty of German family businesses. One reason for this is ‘the avera­ge size of German family businesses and the associa­ted limit­ed possi­bi­li­ty of appoin­ting outside management.

At the same time, the results of a current study by the Regens­burg Chamber of Indus­try and Commer­ce are causing a stir: At 52%, more than half of the 600 entre­pre­neurs survey­ed are planning to hand over their business in the course of the next 5 years. This is around 300 compa­nies. However, 69% of all respond­ents have not yet made any provi­si­ons. Ergo, only 31% of all entre­pre­neurs in the Regens­burg region are concer­ned with their succes­si­on. And this third seems to be in a good positi­on: 24% of all entre­pre­neurs have found a soluti­on, two-thirds of them within the family. However, these two thirds corre­spond to only 16% of all entre­pre­neurs surveyed!

Only 16% of all entre­pre­neurs have made provi­si­ons for the future

In summa­ry, three things can be said:

  1. Only a fraction of all family businesses are contin­ued within the family after a genera­tio­nal change. studies, the propor­ti­on of businesses passed on within the family fell by more than 30% to around 34%. The results of the Regens­burg study may be a statis­ti­cal outlier, but they indica­te the general trend.
  2. Many entre­pre­neurs deal with the issue of their own succes­si­on too late or not at all. One of the most important strate­gic decis­i­ons for the preser­va­ti­on of one’s own entre­pre­neu­ri­al herita­ge is put on the back burner by the majori­ty of entrepreneurs.
    And the situa­ti­on is likely to get worse: Most entre­pre­neurs run their businesses well into retire­ment age. In just ten years, the propor­ti­on of entre­pre­neurs over 60 in Germa­ny has doubled. And the demogra­phic develo­p­ment suggests that this trend will continue.
    In the case of a compa­ny sale, waiting too long is likely to lead to less invest­ment. This has a direct impact on the earning power and thus the value of a company.
  3. The genera­tio­nal change in small and medium-sized businesses is one of the greatest future challenges for the econo­mic develo­p­ment of many regions. Business promo­ters, chambers and banks are alarmed and forced to deal inten­si­ve­ly with the topic. This is becau­se late compa­ny succes­si­ons reduce innova­ti­ve strength and delay urgen­tly needed invest­ments. The resul­ting lower compe­ti­ti­ve­ness of compa­nies ultim­ate­ly endan­gers jobs and our prosperity.

What can entre­pre­neurs do?

It is as simple as it is complex: the key to a successful compa­ny succes­si­on lies in good and early prepa­ra­ti­on of the genera­ti­on change. Becau­se planning a compa­ny succes­si­on and the struc­tu­red search for a succes­sor as well as an order­ly hando­ver process is not a questi­on of weeks or months but of years.

But in the end, econo­mic politi­ci­ans, bankers and advisors can only draw atten­ti­on to this issue. The first step must be taken by an affec­ted entre­pre­neur himself. To ensure an order­ly transi­ti­on, it is advisa­ble to first address the issue from the age of 55. This would be a good time strate­gi­cal­ly. And not too late.

Tips for further reading:

Free guide to the sale of a compa­ny and compa­ny succession

Free webinars on business succession

Practi­cal examp­le of a successful compa­ny succes­si­on in the skilled crafts sector

Clari­fy important questi­ons about business succes­si­on in advance

Family founda­ti­on as an instru­ment for resol­ving succes­si­on within the family

Enter­pri­se value-orien­ted compa­ny valua­ti­on pays off when selling a company

Compa­ny succes­si­on also a topic in the Osnabrück region

The choice of the optimal succes­sor model

The costs of a business succes­si­on or an M&A project

Image: ©tunedin / fotolia.com